The Whiskey Hotline

CONTACT THE WHISKEY HOTLINE: spirits@binnys.com or (888) 817-5898

The Whiskey Hotline team is on a never ending mission. We scour the world for the most interesting, unique and best barrels of spirits we can find. This can take us to Scotland, Taiwan, Washington, Tennessee, Kentucky... Wherever there’s good spirits to be found, we’ll find the best of it and bring it to you at the best price we can.

Barrel Strength Jeppson’s Bourbon Handpicks

Yes, we’ve recently seen plenty of handpicked barrels from Jeppson arrive, but when we find great tasting bourbon at a great price, we strike first. In our last barrel sampling at CH Distillery, they rolled out a couple of sherry casks at the end of the tasting looking for our thoughts. Our thoughts? They both show a greater depth of complexity and incorporate the dark stewed fruit elements we love from sherry perfectly with the robust bourbon. And we’ll take these as well. Grab our latest Jeppson’s handpicks while you can, these are arguably the best deals in bourbon right now.

Jeppson's

Jeppson's Bourbon Barrel Proof Single Barrel #X8 Indiana Binny's Handpicked

750 ml Bottle
$32.99

This is a wonderfully robust and well-balanced bourbon. Quite an inviting nose of baked apple and red cherry, brioche, caramel crème, vanilla toffee and cardamom. On the palate, bright orchard fruit flavors along with warming spices of cinnamon and black peppercorn. The finish is long and pleasant with sweet and spicy flavors fading slowly together.

Jeppson's

Jeppson's Bourbon Barrel Proof Single Barrel #Y34 Indiana Binny's Handpicked

750 ml Bottle
$32.99

A dangerously drinkable delight. On the nose, corn puddin’ with caramel toffee candy, apple butter, vanilla bean, and oak spice. On the palate, fruit intensifies along with rich waves of caramel and vanilla sauce. The finish is lengthy, with a wave of sweeter elements slowly fading into pleasant amounts of oak spice.

Jeppson's

Jeppson's Bourbon Barrel Proof Single Barrel #A2 Indiana Binny's Handpicked

750 ml Bottle
$32.99

On the nose buttered toffee and vanilla laden apple with soft oak spice underneath. On the palate clove and pepper surge with pronounced waves of vanilla apple, toffee, caramel cream, and butterscotch underneath. The finish is balanced and lengthy with a lovely caramel apple flavor persisting with sweet baking spice.

Jeppson's

Jeppson's Bourbon Barrel Proof Single Barrel #Z20 Tennessee Binny's Handpicked

750 ml Bottle
$32.99

Peach blossom and pear with vanilla lanolin, toffee bar, and cinnamon butter on the nose. On the palate, baked pear and peach surge with cinnamon candy and vanilla cream. The finish is pleasant with sweeter flavors giving way to long lasting spicy flavors of candied cinnamon and oak.

Jeppson's

Jeppson's Bourbon Barrel Proof Single Barrel #X1 Indiana Binny's Handpicked

750 ml Bottle
$32.99

A dynamic and complex bourbon with evolving subtleties. On the nose, baked orchard fruits in caramel sauce with vanilla bean and freshly ground cinnamon. Fruitier on the palate with baked apple and pear surging forward with vanilla and caramel underneath as oak spice provides balance. The finish is long lasting with sweet and spice fading slowly together.

Jeppson's

Jeppson's Bourbon Barrel Proof Single Barrel #X4 Indiana Binny's Handpicked

750 ml Bottle
$32.99

On the nose, apple almond cluster with vanilla and caramel candies on cinnamon brioche. On the palate, pleasant amounts of oak spice leap into balance with baked orchard fruits with vanilla, caramel, and spicy cinnamon underneath. The finish is lengthy with sweeter elements from the palate giving way to cardamom and clove.

Sherry Cask

Jeppson's Bourbon Finished in Sherry Cask #SH1 Indiana Binny's Handpicked

750 ml Bottle
$37.99

Flavor abounds throughout this complex stunner. On the nose, vanilla and butterscotch candies with baked apple and stewed plum. The sherry barrel is clear on the palate with raisin and stewed plum as classic bourbon flavors of vanilla, baked orchard fruits, and toffee dance in harmony. The finish shows nice length with layers of flavors fading from sweeter fruit flavors into oak spice.

Sherry Cask

Jeppson's Bourbon Finished in Sherry Cask #SH10 Indiana Binny's Handpicked

750 ml Bottle
$37.99

A wonderful sipping bourbon for cold nights by the fire. On the nose, golden raisin with apple chutney, vanilla pod, chocolate covered toffee, and cinnamon candy. An initial burst of oak on the palate with a transition to stewed plum, raisins on sliced apple with caramel candy, and cardamom. The finish is complex with sweeter fruit flavors and spicy oak fading in unison ever so slowly. Complex and richly layered.

Putting the Finishing Touches on Rye Whiskey

Tuthilltown Spirits, distiller of Hudson whiskies, is one of the old guard of American craft spirits producers. They’ve been honing that craft for over 15 years now, but they still have a few surprises up their sleeve. At The Whiskey Hotline, we taste a LOT of young, small distillery rye whiskey. While most these days are quite good, they do tend to blend together at times, with only a few being memorable. These new barrel finished ryes, in maple syrup and peated Scotch whisky barrels, stand out amongst their peers. They aren’t dominated by the barrel finish though, but weave the lean rye spice notes through the barrel notes creating a delicious tapestry of complex flavors.

Short Stack

Hudson Whiskey NY Short Stack Straight Rye Finished in Maple Syrup Barrels

750 ml Bottle
$54.99

Soft herbal notes on the nose reveal the rye heritage but they are softened by toffee bar, vanilla cream, maple fudge and anise. The rye spice punches back against the confectionary notes on the palate with clove, oak and cinnamon all giving balance. The finish is lengthy with spice outlasting sweeter flavors.

Back Room Deal

Hudson Whiskey NY Back Room Deal Straight Rye Finished in Peated Scotch Barrels

750 ml Bottle
$54.99

Soft waves of peat mingle nicely with rich chocolate, toffee-butter, vanilla bean and dried apple on the nose. The palate reveals bittersweet chocolate, vanilla, toffee, cherry, and cinnamon. The finish is soft and pleasant with sweeter flavors fading slowly into oak spice and soft smoke. A nice sipper that will also make some dynamic cocktails.

New Handpicked Single Barrels

2021 is off to a cracking start with handpicked bourbons. This is our third round of barrels from Wilderness Trail and the Danville, Kentucky upstart continues to impress. Their combination of sweet mash whiskies, proper aging and extremely low entry proofs, as low as 100 for the rye, make rich, mouthcoating whiskies worthy of top shelf placement in any collection.

Bourbon

Wilderness Trail High Rye Bourbon Single Barrel #15E02-M6 Binny's Handpicked

750 ml Bottle
$59.99

On the nose, baked red apples with caramel crème, chocolate covered toffee, toasted coconut and cinnamon powder. On the palate, baked orchard fruits are pronounced along with vanilla candy, bittersweet chocolate, caramel and oak spice. The finish is long and pleasant with spice outlasting sweeter elements. A full-flavored sipper.

Bourbon

Wilderness Trail High Rye Bourbon Single Barrel #15E31-9 Binny's Handpicked

750 ml Bottle
$59.99

The rich and fruity nose holds aromas of tropical and orchard fruits along with cinnamon and vanilla candies. On the palate, fruit elements from the nose give way to herbal rye, clove and anise, and a dusting of cocoa powder. The fruit returns in the finish fading into long lasting sweet baking spice. Bold and rich.

Bourbon

Wilderness Trail High Rye Bourbon Single Barrel #15E31-6 Binny's Handpicked

750 ml Bottle
$59.99

Sweet and confectionary nose, apple chutney and baked pear along with vanilla bean, caramel candy, toffee and cinnamon candy. On the palate, toasted oak spice surges to match the richness of fruit. The finish is decidedly on the spicy side as fruit gives way to long lasting cardamom and cinnamon.

Rye

Wilderness Trail Rye Single Barrel #15L21-H19 Binny's Handpicked

750 ml Bottle
$54.99

Lovely notes of peach and pear leap from the glass along with hard vanilla candies, caramel crème, and the unmistakable herbal spice of rye. On the palate, wintergreen and red rope licorice along with peach and pear and a sweet backbone of toasted oak and caramel. The finish is long and round with more red rope licorice and pear lingering alongside tingling cinnamon. A well-rounded firecracker.

Rye

Wilderness Trail Rye Single Barrel #15L21-A5 Binny's Handpicked

750 ml Bottle
$54.99

On the nose, caramel wafer and baked apple along with cinnamon toast and vanilla crème. A beautifully balanced palate of fruit flavors from the nose with a hefty dose of rye spice along with clove and oak. The finish is lengthy and pleasant with sweeter elements fading into an enduring, rich oak spice. A gorgeous rye.

A Toast to Oak

If you haven’t picked up any of the Lucky Seven bourbons yet you have been missing out. Bardstown juice, perfectly matured and priced to drink. Their latest limited release doubles down on the barrel treatment with a second maturation in a toasted barrel. A slow toast in a barrel brings more of the sweet and fruity character out in the finished whiskey, highlighting the vanilla and coconut without as big of a wallop of spice that new oak can deliver.

Lucky Seven 'The Holiday Toast' Double Oak Straight Kentucky Bourbon

Lucky Seven 'The Holiday Toast' Double Oak Straight Kentucky Bourbon

750 ml Bottle
$69.99

The first thing that comes to mind, is that this is perfectly matured liquid. Baked orchard fruits are ever present on the nose, but layers of oak continue to reveal depth and are buttressed with vanilla, caramel candy and cinnamon candy. On the palate, rich waves of fruit spring forth and are perfectly balanced with oak flavors as vanilla, coconut, caramel, and cinnamon swirl. The finish is long and evolving as sweet and spice dance together while the core of baked apples and toasted coconut persists. A complex, rich and spicy bourbon.

The Softer Side of Smoke

The story of Whiskey and Ireland have been intertwined for many hundreds of years. It is from this rich history that the name of Teeling’s newest whiskey pays homage. Blackpitts was an area in Dublin that housed many industries, including a crucial component for whiskey distillation, grain maltings. This area, located just behind the new Teeling distillery, housed the country’s largest producers of malted barley. Historically, all of that barley would have been malted using peat-fueled fires, giving the whiskey a smokey character. With Blackpitts, the earthy smoke is tempered a bit by the traditional triple pot still distillation and graceful aging in ex-Sauternes wine casks. What’s old is new again with this peated single malt.

Stereo

Teeling Blackpitts Peated Irish Single Malt

750 ml Bottle
$69.99

On the nose, soft burning embers of peat along with violets and vanilla blossoms, jammy fruits, caramel, and toffee underneath. On the palate, ripe orchard fruits arrive with soft honey-drizzled peaches, dried apricots and a bubbling of baking spices percolating below. The finish is lovely, as sweet and spice from the nose and palate slowly give way to a long lasting and pleasant peat smoke. An absolutely gorgeous malt using peat smoke and barrel enhancements of Sauternes to achieve the delicate balance of smoke, sweet, and spice. Well done.

Transatlantic Rum Journey

The world's first African and Caribbean Rum is one worth checking out. Bottled up at one of the Hotline’s favorite rum producers, Foursquare. The skill of the blender is on full display with this pleasant sipper made from rums distilled in Mauritius and Barbados. The taste isn’t the only thing to get excited about here, 5% of the company profits at Equiano are donated to ground-level freedom and equality projects. A fitting tribute to the man the rum is named after, Olaudah Equiano, an African sold into bondage who eventually bought his way out and became an influential abolitionist.

Stereo

The Equiano Afro Caribbean Rum

750 ml Bottle
$49.99

A blend of rums aged up to 8 years in tropic climates and married in ex-bourbon and Cognac casks before being bottled without added sugar, flavoring, or color. On the nose, warming oak spice and decadent sweet molasses intertwine with toffee, caramelized banana and dried plum. The molasses heavy pedigree is on full display on the palate with caramel cream, vanilla toffee, clove, stewed plum and lingering black pepper. The finish is long and pleasant with sweeter flavors slowly taking over spice elements. A wonderful sipping rum showing balance without losing depth.

Perfectly Aged Porker

Two new handpicked 15 year old barrels from WhistlePig have arrived. These unctuous ungulates, bottled at cask strength and without chill filtration, are exactly the big and chewy whiskies we want on these cold winter nights.

Stereo

WhistlePig 15 year old Straight Rye Single Barrel #1326 Hogfather II: Vito Pigleone Binny's Handpicked

750 ml Bottle
$249.99

Cinnamon baked apples, toasted oak, classic rye spice and a mélange of baking spices and pepper on the nose. The palate entry is notably thick and chewy, showing pronounced caramel, vanilla and brown sugar before a transition to herbal rye and soft mint. The finish just goes on and on with a mellow burn balanced by sweet oak and vanilla notes. A testament to letting rye age.

Stereo

WhistlePig 15 year old Straight Rye Single Barrel #1449 Hogfather III: Michael Pigleone Binny's Handpicked

750 ml Bottle
$249.99

More herbal, punchy and oak-forward on the nose here initially, but with some time to breathe sweeter molasses and brown sugar notes emerge. Rich and mouth coating on the palate, it’s a symphony of spice, herbs, oak and vanilla. Undoubtedly rye from front to back with waves of mint, clove, and pepper. The finish is tempered by some sweeter vanilla and caramel before a crescendo of rye bursts and fades slowly. World class whiskey, and one of the finest ryes we have tasted.

Introducing to Illinois: Woody Creek Limited Edition Wheated Bourbon

Some of our picks for best whiskies this past year have been from Woody Creek Distillers in Colorado, makers of a delicious high rye bourbon and an absolutely stellar rye whiskey. Building upon that pedigree is a new limited release, a 6 year old wheated bourbon! It’s full of caramelized fruit and sweet vanilla notes over a soft and smooth body. Wheated bourbons of this quality are exceedingly rare, and this stands shoulder to shoulder with those in the upper echelon of the whiskey world, especially considering the price. Grab it while you can.

Woody Creek 6 year old Wheated Bourbon

Woody Creek 6 year old Wheated Bourbon

750 ml Bottle
$49.99

The nose is approachable with vanilla cream and poached peach, caramel wafers, vanilla covered almond, and a gentle touch of oak spice. On the palate, vanilla soaked peach and apple with sweet caramel, toffee, more vanilla, and spiced cherries. The finish is lengthy with rich fruit fading into oak spice and baked peach. A gorgeous sipper that punches well above its price.

Clark & Sheffield Small Batch Vodka

Introducing the newest member of our Clark & Sheffield family, Small Batch Bourbon. Clark & Sheffield Small Batch bourbon hails from Sazerac’s Bardstown, KY distillery and is 5 years old and 90 proof. A versatile whiskey equally at home on the rocks or in your favorite cocktail and is maybe the best deal in our ever-expanding bourbon aisle. A gentle and flavorful sipper, and a full flavored but budget priced mixer, this bourbon does it all.

Clark & Sheffield Small Batch Bourbon

Clark & Sheffield Small Batch Bourbon

1.75 L Bottle
$24.99
$29.99

Cherries, brown sugar, pepper and vanilla are all layered throughout the robust nose. The soft and round palate brings a touch more sweetness with strong vanilla, caramelized sugars and sweet corn. Cinnamon and clove build gradually giving balance to the sweeter flavors throughout the long finish.