The Binny's Blog Select a category:

An Impromptu Blind Vodka Tasting

Early this afternoon I was sitting in my office doing item data entry (the boring part of my job) when by boss looked in and invited me to a blind vodka tasting (the exciting part of my job).  He said, You can blog about it. That’s all the invitation I need.


The Binny’s vodka buyer’s office was already full of people spirit company representatives, mostly so I stood in the hallway, with four styrofoam cups, one marked A, one marked B, one marked C, and one marked SPIT. They told me to put them in order of cost.


I sniffed, sipped, and spat the three samples. Vodka A had a fair amount of chemical in the nose and palate, with a relatively clean finish.  Vodka B had a much cleaner nose, and slightly more dimension on the palate. Vodka C had an equally clean nose with a noticeably thicker mouthfeel. I guessed that C was the most expensive, followed by B, and named A as the cheapest.


It turns out I was right.


The other blind tasters knew the three brands, and were just trying to guess which was which. Aside from a little confusion here and there, they were mostly right. The most expensive was a new luxury vodka called Diamond Standard Vodka, ringing in at about $80, which boasts a Diamond Filtration process.  I can’t even imagine that.  The vodka in the middleof the price range was another new one called Death’s Door Vodka, from Door County in Wisconsin, which will sell somewhere in the mid-30’s. And least expensive was Burnett’s, which I have to admit was much, much better than I would have guessed, though it seemed obvious as the least expensive (It’s $12 for a 1.75L).


My boss asked us all how we could tell which was which. We all threw in pretty much the same response tasting vodka is mostly about purity, lack of chemical overtones on the nose and finish, and maybe about texture and flavors if they’re in there. He then asked us if we’d still be able to tell the difference if each vodka were mixed into a glass of orange juice.  That’s a lot harder.


I told them about a vodka I had purchased recently, a certain new organic vodka. I told everybody about how it completely ruined any drink it went into about how the drink would taste fine until the finish, and how the vodka would just leave an absolutely appalling medicinal aftertaste.


The representative for that particular new brand of organic vodka was in the room, and immediately pointed out how consumers at tastings held at various Binny’s locations have responded positively to that particular new organic vodka, and gave me a sheet of statistics a list of stores, the number of customers who tasted the vodka at each store, and the number of bottles those customers purchased. The information is very thorough. I have to admit that consumers are responding quite positively to that particular new organic vodka. He pointed out that I probably analyze the vodka more than the average consumer.


He’s right, so I only protested a little. I told them about this time that I was going to a concert (drinks are too damned expensive at concerts) and that we stopped at a Taco Bell to get some Frutista Freezes to mix the vodka in for the walk across the huge parking lot to the front gates of the arena….


Wait, what? My boss said. What’s a Frutisian Freezer?


It’s like this sort of slushy thing you get at Taco Bell, I said. It’s like, um, mango and pineapple or strawberry. They’re really super sweet. Anyway, we mixed that with the organic vodka and it still tasted like chemicals.


My boss smirked and said, See, that’s a blog post right there.


I guess it is.

5 thoughts on “An Impromptu Blind Vodka Tasting

  1. I hope all this ‘evidence’ this person had on that specific organic vodka wasn’t collected soley from tasters at stores. I would call that HIGHLY unscientific.

  2. Were the tasters first told it was organic? Much like being told something is expensive, therefore it must be good, fans of “organic” tend to approve more of the perceived virtue of the product rather than the end result.

  3. Just wondering why you give no discounts on your spirits.I have a Binny’s card and would like to see dicounts on Vodka and Rum . Your loyal customers deserve this.

  4. That’s a little harsh, Greg M.Pat, we do offer regular Member’s Only Pricing Specials on many spirit items. Check out our weekly ad in the Chicago Tribune Good Eating section on Wednesday, or on the home page by clicking on the “What’s on Sale?” link over on the left. Or stop by a store, you’ll see the Member’s Only Pricing Specials tags in the spirits aisles.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Create New List

List Info

Sign In

An email address is required.
Please enter your password.


Select Your Store


Shipping Your Order?

Use our Online Store


Select Your Store



Binny's offers shipping within the state of Illinois for select items. Our web site will not allow orders placed for shipment outside of Illinois.


Shipping/Store Pickup Options

Would you like to have your order shipped or would you like to come pick it up at a Binny's near you?
Ask Later »

Add To List

Login or register to use lists. Save your favorite products and share lists with friends.


Provide Feedback

We Appreciate Your Feedback

Location Warning

Unable to determine your location. Please check your browser settings or enter your zip code or city and state into the search box.