Insights for everything wine, spirits, beer and more!
 
Mar 12 2010

Brag to Me

Posted by Greg Versch at 5:50 PM
2 comments
- Categories: Wine



  A funny thing about being in retail wine sales is that one is often given the opportunity to taste wine, but it's always what is currently available, which means it's almost always young. A big part of being able to appreciate wine is understanding time and its affects, which can only come from experience, and experience can be scarce when one is exposed only to the youth of current releases.

  For example, I was fortunate to attend a Bordeaux tasting on Wednesday that included many 2009 barrel samples, mostly reasonably priced bottlings retailing in the mid-teens to just under $100 a bottle. The samples are monstrously tannic right now, with huge plummy fruit covering up almost all other complexities. How will they turn out? I can't really tell.

  -----

  A few weeks ago, I shared a nice dinner with a group of wine guys at a suburban Italian BYO. Bruschetta, spinach soup, eggplant parmesan, and all the wine you can carry makes for a great dinner. Plus the company, of course.

  Among the plethora of great wine we shared that night was one especially memorable highlight – a bottle of 1975 Pichon Lalande. This was the oldest wine I can remember tasting (besides aged port and sherry) since the 1981 Montecillo Rioja I had over a year ago. The 1981 was terrible; it really showed its age.

  The '75 Pichon Lalande was a wine for reflection. It poured a healthy brick red, much more red than the brown I was expecing. Elegance on the nose, and the palate showed a surprising amount of tart red fruit, a little spice, and a lots of sturdy, drying, palate-gripping tannins on the finish. Kurt, my friend who brought the bottle, was concerned by Robert Parker's most recent review of the wine (published in 1996) saying the wine was already past its prime, even back then. If anything, I appreciate the wine for its defiance of this sentiment – I doubt it will improve much more with age, but this old wine is still alive and kicking.

  So that was the oldest wine I'd tried in a while, until this morning. The new record setter? 1967 Dr Fischer Ockfener Bockstein Riesling Auslese. I'm told 1967 was not a notable year in Germany, or pretty much anywhere else. I'll have to trust my sources; I wasn't around.

  Still, the wine was beautiful. The cork disintegrated into a hundred pieces, of course. It poured a deep gold, with a quiet nose of honey and baking spice and mustiness. The riesling was restrained and elegant, much of the expected sugar having backed off. It showed thin citrus fruit like lemon peel (maybe orange peel?). But it was the strong, fresh acidity, not quite as bracing as a dry sherry, that defined this (42+ year old!) wine and gave it focus.

  Without a doubt, a big part of the experience, of the joy, of tasting these aged wines is in their scarcity. There is novelty in such a thing existing at all, and I find myself impressed simply by the specialness of the occasion. I wonder how I would have reacted if I were unaware of the vintages involved, if I were tasing these wines blindly. Would I appreciate the delicate, elegant nature of age, or would I complain at the lack of up front fruit?

  -----

  So that's my bragging, now here's your chance to brag to me. Tell me about the oldest wine you've tasted recently. How was it? Do you wish you had waited longer? Acted sooner? If you have a bunch of old stuff stashed away, open it! Wine is for drinking!

Comments

Dave Wieser  Wine Manager-Willowbrook

Dave Wieser Wine Manager-Willowbrook wrote on 03/23/10 7:36 PM

Last year in Germany at Dr Heidemann's, the Pauly family invited the group I was with into their private cellar and opened up a 1959 Bernkasteler Badstube Spatlese. It was a hue of medium gold and the aroma was of honeyed peaches. For as old as it was, it still had some acidity to it, proving that you can age white wine. Such a treat!
JC

JC wrote on 09/07/10 9:49 PM

1955 Chateau Latour. Was a bit skeptical before tasting, but it was delicious. Brick red, herbaceous, sour cherries, mushrooms, leather. Incredible effort! Although it was not the best wine I've ever had; it was a real pleasure to enjoy a wine that was twice as old as I am.

Write your comment



(it will not be displayed)



Leave this field empty:

BeerRSS
CigarRSS
EventsRSS
MailbagRSS
SpiritsRSS
VideoRSS
WineRSS
February 2012 (1)
January 2012 (22)
December 2011 (24)
November 2011 (23)
October 2011 (31)
September 2011 (24)
August 2011 (13)
July 2011 (13)
June 2011 (10)
May 2011 (19)
April 2011 (15)
March 2011 (17)
February 2011 (13)
January 2011 (12)
December 2010 (10)
November 2010 (10)
October 2010 (10)
September 2010 (12)
August 2010 (17)
July 2010 (13)
June 2010 (8)
May 2010 (12)
April 2010 (14)
March 2010 (15)
February 2010 (11)
January 2010 (11)
December 2009 (10)
November 2009 (12)
October 2009 (10)
September 2009 (17)
August 2009 (17)
July 2009 (17)
June 2009 (18)
May 2009 (21)
April 2009 (20)
March 2009 (23)
February 2009 (7)


Add to Google Reader or Homepage
Add to My AOL
Subscribe in NewsGator Online
Fine Wine |  Spirits |  Beer & Bev |  Cigars |  Blogs |  Gifts & More |  Retail Stores |  Contact Us
Weekly Specials |  Member Specials |  Binny's Card Membership |  FAQ | Policies | Mobile
Facebook facebook | Twitter twitter
© Copyright 1999-2012 Gold Standard Enterprises All rights reserved.